.png)
OutSail vs G2: Discover the difference between HR tech reviews and real HR software comparison. Get an unbiased HR tech guide for expert, vendor-matched recommendations.
When you're searching for HR technology, you'll inevitably land on G2 or similar review platforms. These sites offer thousands of user reviews, star ratings, and feature comparisons across hundreds of vendors. They're valuable resources for initial research—but they're fundamentally different from working with an expert advisory service like OutSail.
The distinction isn't just about reviews versus recommendations. It's about incentive structures, depth of guidance, and where the relationship ends. One model is designed to generate demo meetings. The other is built to drive successful software selections.
If you're a Head of HR, People Operations leader, or business owner facing a significant HR tech investment, knowing this difference could save you months of wasted time and hundreds of thousands of dollars in suboptimal choices.
Let's break down exactly how these two approaches differ—and what that means for your software selection process.
G2 operates on an advertising and lead generation model. Vendors pay to be listed prominently on the platform, boost their profiles, and appear in sponsored placements. The platform earns revenue in several ways:
Here's what this means: G2 is most successful when you're clicking on multiple vendor profiles and booking numerous demo meetings. The platform's goal is to facilitate connections between buyers and as many sellers as possible. Volume drives their business.
There's nothing inherently wrong with this model—it works for many industries and provides value. But it creates specific incentives that shape how information is presented and what actions are encouraged.
OutSail gets paid differently: we receive a placement fee from software vendors only when you make a successful selection and sign a contract. If you don't choose a vendor, we don't get paid. If you choose a vendor but it's not the right fit, we've failed.
This creates powerful alignment between our success and yours. We're incentivized to:
We only win when you win. That's not marketing talk—it's the literal structure of how we get paid.
When you use G2 to research HR software, here's typically what happens:
You start by browsing categories like "HRIS," "Applicant Tracking Systems," or "Performance Management." You'll see dozens or hundreds of options, each with star ratings and review counts. You read through user reviews—some glowing, some critical, many from users with very different needs than yours.
You create a list of 8-12 vendors that look promising based on reviews and feature lists. You reach out to each one or book demos through G2. Over the next 4-8 weeks, you sit through 8-12 sales presentations, each one 60-90 minutes long. Every vendor tells you they're the perfect fit.
Now you have 8-12 proposals, different pricing structures, varying contract terms, and a spreadsheet that's becoming unwieldy. You're trying to compare vendors on features you may not fully grasp, pricing models that aren't apples-to-apples, and implementation timelines that all sound optimistic.
At this point, G2's job is done. You've had your meetings. The platform provided the reviews and facilitated the connections. What happens next is entirely up to you.
When you work with OutSail, the process looks different from day one:
When your software search is driven by reviews and clicks rather than expert guidance, several hidden costs emerge:
The average HR leader spends 80-120 hours on software selection when using a review-driven approach. That includes researching vendors, scheduling demos, sitting through presentations, comparing proposals, and negotiating. For a VP of HR earning $150K annually, that's $6,000-$9,000 in opportunity cost alone.
With OutSail's guided approach, that typically drops to 40-50 hours because you're not evaluating mismatched vendors or figuring out negotiations on your own.
Without market knowledge, you accept the first proposal. Vendors know this. The difference between "first offer" and "negotiated rate" averages 15-25% on annual software costs. On a $100K annual contract, that's $15,000-$25,000 left on the table—year after year.
Industry data shows that 30-40% of HR tech implementations fail or severely underperform expectations. Often, this traces back to poor vendor fit that wasn't apparent during demos. When your advisor is only paid on successful selections, they're incentivized to prevent these mismatches.
Reviews tell you what others experienced, but they don't tell you what you'll experience. A vendor might have glowing reviews from mid-market manufacturing companies, but if you're an enterprise tech company, your needs are different. Expert guidance identifies these gaps before you sign.
Reviews are inputs. Recommendations are outcomes of expert analysis.
Many smart buyers use both: G2 for initial research and sentiment checks, OutSail for the actual selection process.
At the end of the day, the core difference between OutSail and G2 isn't about reviews versus recommendations—it's about incentive alignment.
A platform that profits from demo meetings wants you taking lots of demos. An advisory service that profits from successful selections wants you making great choices.
Both can be valuable at different stages of your journey. But when it's time to actually make a decision—when you're ready to invest six or seven figures annually in HR technology that will impact every employee—you want someone whose success is tied directly to yours.
If you're beginning your HR software search and want expert guidance from day one, we're here to help.
Download our HRIS Landscape Report for a comprehensive breakdown of today's top HR platforms, including honest assessments of strengths, weaknesses, and ideal customer profiles for each.
Compare Vendors with OutSail and experience the difference between anonymous reviews and expert recommendations. We'll assess your needs, match you with the three to four best-fit vendors, and guide you through the evaluation, negotiation, and implementation process.
Because the goal isn't more demos. It's the right decision.
