Evaluating HR Systems: Avoiding Overcommitment and Overselling

Discover how to select the best HR system for your organization with our guide on avoiding vendor overselling and ensuring a perfect match for your HR needs.

Brett Ungashick
OutSail HRIS Advisor
November 14, 2023
HR system evaluation checklist

Selecting the appropriate human resource (HR) system is crucial in determining an organization's ability to manage its workforce, streamline procedures, and achieve overall success. However, the process of assessing HR systems can pose several challenges, especially when it comes to avoiding overselling by vendors and over-commitment by organizations themselves. HR management is a rapidly changing field, and choosing the right HR system is key to success.

Working with a free HRIS advisor like OutSail can help ensure you efficiently and effectively find the right solution

Critical Evaluation – The Cornerstone of Sound Decision-Making

A critical evaluation of HR systems is essential to ensure that the chosen solution aligns with the organization's specific needs, challenges, and long-term goals. This evaluation should comprehensively assess the system's functionality, fit, and overall value proposition.

The success of an HR system implementation is contingent upon its seamless alignment with an organization's unique needs, challenges, and long-term strategic goals. A meticulous evaluation process covering functionality, fit, and overall value proposition serves as the cornerstone for sound decision-making in this critical domain.

Functionality: The Bedrock of HR System Evaluation

At the heart of any HR system evaluation lies its functionality, representing the core capabilities that enable an organization to streamline its HR processes. A thorough examination is necessary to ensure that the system lives up to its promises, particularly in supporting key functions such as recruitment, payroll, performance management, and talent development. The evaluation process should delve into the system's capacity to accommodate the organization's specific workflows, handle varying data volumes, and meet diverse reporting requirements. A robust HR system addresses current needs and demonstrates scalability to accommodate future growth and evolving business dynamics.

Fit: Seamless Integration and Adaptability

The effectiveness of an HR system is not confined to its standalone capabilities; its ability to integrate seamlessly with existing IT infrastructure and business processes is equally crucial. Organizations should evaluate how well the system aligns with their current technology stack, ensuring a smooth transition and minimal disruption during implementation. Moreover, a forward-looking assessment of the system's adaptability to future changes and growth is paramount. An HR system that proves flexible and resilient in the face of evolving business requirements ensures long-term value and return on investment.

Comprehensive Assessment: Ensuring Overall Value Proposition

Beyond functionality and fit, a comprehensive evaluation should consider the overall value proposition of the HR system. This involves weighing the solution's cost-effectiveness against its benefits to the organization. Factors such as user experience, vendor support, and the system's potential for customization should be thoroughly examined. A well-rounded understanding of the total cost of ownership, including implementation, training, and maintenance costs, is essential for making informed decisions that align with the organization's financial objectives.

Value Proposition: Weighing the Benefits Against the Costs

The evaluation should not only assess the system's capabilities but also its overall value proposition. Organizations must carefully consider the system's return on investment (ROI), taking into account the potential benefits in terms of improved efficiency, reduced costs, and enhanced employee engagement.

Identifying Red Flags: Spotting Overselling Tactics

Vendors often employ overselling tactics to exaggerate the capabilities of their HR systems, leading to unrealistic expectations and potential disappointment. Organizations must be vigilant in identifying these red flags, which may include:

1. Unrealistic Promises of Quick Fixes and Instant Solutions:

One prevalent red flag is the promise of quick fixes and instant solutions. Vendors might exaggerate the speed at which their HR system can address organizational challenges. Organizations should exercise caution when confronted with claims of immediate problem resolution, as effective HR systems require thoughtful implementation, adaptation, and integration with existing processes.

2. Lack of Transparency Regarding System Limitations and Potential Challenges:

Transparency is key in any business transaction, and the same holds true for HR system vendors. Red flags may arise when vendors fail to communicate the limitations of their systems openly. An absence of discussions about potential challenges or constraints can lead to unmet expectations. A thorough vendor should provide clear insights into the capabilities and constraints of their HR system to foster a realistic understanding.

3. Overemphasis on Features That May Not Align With the Organization's Needs:

Vendors may emphasize features that sound impressive but need to be aligned with the specific needs of the organization. It is essential for organizations to identify their core requirements and critically assess whether the highlighted features contribute directly to addressing those needs. A misalignment between the emphasized features and the organization's actual requirements can signal overselling.

4. Exaggerated Claims of ROI Without Providing Concrete Data or Case Studies:

Return on Investment (ROI) is a critical consideration in HR system evaluation. Red flags emerge when vendors make grand claims about the potential ROI without substantiating them with concrete data or relevant case studies. Organizations should request evidence supporting the proclaimed ROI and scrutinize the reliability of such assertions.

Asking the Right Questions: Engaging in Informed Vendor Discussions

Effective communication with vendors is crucial to gain a clear understanding of the HR system's true capabilities and avoid overselling. Organizations should prepare a list of insightful questions to ask vendors during the evaluation process, such as:

  • How does the system address the organization's specific needs and challenges?
  • What is the system's track record in similar organizations?
  • How will the vendor support the implementation and ongoing maintenance of the system?
  • What are the system's limitations, and how will they be addressed?
  • What are the vendor's pricing models and licensing terms?

Trial and Testing: Experiencing the System Before Commitment

Organizations should never commit to an HR system without conducting thorough trials and demonstrations. This hands-on experience allows stakeholders to test the system's functionality, assess user-friendliness, and identify potential issues before making a final decision.

Conclusion: A Sound Investment in the Future of HR

A rigorous evaluation process is not just about selecting the right HR system; it is about making a sound investment in the future of HR. By critically assessing functionality, fit, and value proposition, organizations can avoid overcommitment and overselling, ensuring that they choose an HR system that will empower their workforce, optimize processes, and contribute to long-term success.

2024 HRIS 
Landscape Report
Read OutSail's 2024 HRIS Report with write-ups on 30+ leading vendors
Thank you! You can download your report at this link
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
Unsure about your software needs?
Use our HRIS Requirements Builder to quickly identify your must-have & nice-to-haves
Brett Ungashick
OutSail HRIS Advisor
Accelerate your HRIS selection process with free support
Thank you! Our team will reach out to you shortly
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

Meet the Author

Brett Ungashick
OutSail HRIS Advisor
Brett Ungashick, the friendly face behind OutSail, started his career at LinkedIn, selling HR software. This experience sparked an idea, leading him to create OutSail in 2018. Based in Denver, OutSail simplifies the HR software selection process, and Brett's hands-on approach has already helped over 1,000 companies, including SalesLoft, Hudl and DoorDash. He's a go-to guy for all things HR Tech, supporting companies in every industry and across 20+ countries. When he's not demystifying HR tech, you'll find Brett enjoying a round of golf or skiing down Colorado's slopes, always happy to chat about work or play.


Everything you need to know about OutSail
What is OutSail?
OutSail is the first-ever broker of HR Software. We offer market insights, evaluation tools & advisory services to help organizations research, evaluate and select the right HR software. And best of all - OutSail is free!
How is OutSail free?
OutSail is free due to our one-of-a-kind software broker model. When a company makes a purchase through OutSail, the winning vendor owes us a small fee for making the introduction.

No Hidden Fees - You don't pay for our services and the vendors don't pass our costs along either
Vendor Agnostic - OutSail partners with 220+ HR Tech vendors including every market leader
What are the benefits of OutSail?
1.) Market Insights: Access the industry's most trusted data. Read user reviews of every leading HRIS vendor. Access verified pricing data. Use proprietary tools to sort & filter by your selection criteria.
2.) Evaluation Tools: Access to project plans & timelines. Customize your own scorecard tools. Leverage expert-generated demo questions. Collaborate with your team
3.) Advisory Services: Work with HRIS industry experts. Assistance during proposal review and guidance for negotiations. Implementation readiness
What if I'm a broker, consultant or vendor?
We love partnering with brokers & consultants and bringing innovative vendors to our customers. Follow those links to learn more about how we can partner together and bring OutSail's benefits to your customers.

The Future of Software Buying

See why modern buyers prefer OutSail's broker model when buying their next HRIS